Trustee Breach of Fiduciary Duty Attorneys in Saratoga, CA
Enforcing a trustee's duties to the beneficiaries throughout Silicon Valley & the Bay Area.
Request a Free Consultation →Understanding a Trustee's Breach of Fiduciary Duty in California
A trustee accepts one of the highest duties recognized under California law: managing trust assets solely for the beneficiaries' benefit.
When a trustee ignores that obligation, through self-dealing, favoritism, negligent investing, or simply failing to keep beneficiaries informed, beneficiaries can pursue a breach of fiduciary duty claim to recover what the trust has lost.
California's Probate Code sets out specific duties every trustee must follow.
These include:
- The duty of loyalty to act solely in the beneficiaries' interest.
- The duty of impartiality among multiple beneficiaries.
- The duty to invest and manage trust assets prudently.
- The duty to keep beneficiaries reasonably informed and to account for the trust's administration.
A breach of any one of these duties can expose a trustee to personal liability.
These duties aren't abstract, they show up in patterns we see again and again.
- A trustee living in a trust-owned property without paying rent.
- A trustee selling a trust asset to a friend or family member below its market value.
- A trustee paying themselves fees without disclosing the amount or the basis for them.
- A trustee favoring one branch of the family over another in distributions.
None of these facts alone proves a breach, but a pattern like this is often where a closer look starts.
Because trustees often control the only records of how trust assets have been used, breaches can go unnoticed for years.
They often surface only when a beneficiary requests an accounting and the numbers don't add up. Once a breach is discovered, prompt action preserves evidence, limits further losses to the trust, and positions beneficiaries to recover through a surcharge, removal, or both.
The usual obstacle is not the law, it is the records. Beneficiaries often suspect a problem and have almost nothing in writing, because the trustee holds the documents. That is a normal starting position and not a reason to assume you cannot make a case. There are established ways to compel a trustee to produce records and to account, and in our experience the response to a properly framed demand is often more revealing than the records themselves.
What Our Fiduciary Duty Attorneys Do
Trustee Breach of Fiduciary Duty FAQs
A trustee owes beneficiaries the duty of loyalty, requiring them to act solely in the beneficiaries' interest; the duty of impartiality among beneficiaries with different interests; the duty to administer the trust prudently, including making sound investment decisions; and the duty to keep beneficiaries reasonably informed, including providing accountings on request.
Self-dealing occurs when a trustee uses trust assets or their position for personal benefit rather than the beneficiaries', for example, buying trust property at a below-market price, paying themselves excessive fees, or investing trust funds in a business they personally control. California law treats most self-dealing transactions as presumptively a breach of trust.
Breach of fiduciary duty claims typically rely on the trust accounting, financial records, and correspondence documenting the trustee's decisions. We compare the trustee's actions against the duties imposed by the trust instrument and the Probate Code, looking for unexplained transfers, poor investment choices, undisclosed conflicts, or missed distributions.
Beneficiaries can pursue a surcharge, which may require a trustee to restore losses caused by the breach, surrender profits obtained through the breach, or compensate the trust for profits it would otherwise have earned. Attorney's fees and costs may also be recoverable in circumstances authorized by the Probate Code or other applicable law, including certain accounting disputes involving unreasonable and bad-faith conduct. Courts may also remove the trustee and appoint a successor to prevent further harm.
Not automatically. Trustees are held to a standard of prudent management, not a guarantee of investment performance, and reasonable losses from a properly diversified, considered strategy are not typically a breach. Liability generally arises when a trustee invests imprudently, fails to diversify, or ignores the trust's specific investment directions.
California generally requires a trustee to provide an accounting to beneficiaries at least annually, upon a change of trustee, and upon termination of the trust, unless the trust document waives this requirement. Beneficiaries can also petition the court to compel an accounting if a trustee refuses or unreasonably delays.
Yes. Many claims arise from incomplete communication or reasonable, good-faith decisions that beneficiaries later question with hindsight. An experienced attorney can help you assemble documentation supporting your decisions, respond to accounting demands, and defend your administration of the trust in court if necessary.
Results-Driven. Personally Invested.
What Our Clients Say
Results depend on the specific facts and law of each matter. Prior results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any other case.